gts bar.webp

Black and white downward pointing arrow sign

about

Goody Two Shoes brings a whole new experience to Bay Shore’s Main Street! Goody Two Shoes is a place to let out all your inhibitions after being on your best behavior all day long! With our craft cocktails and perfectly curated menu, you’ll feel real good when you’re hanging out with us!

Exterior of a store named 'Good Two Shoes Vice & Vices' with black and white striped awnings and customers gathered outside.

check out our

Food Menu

DRINK Menu

check out our

check out our

BRUNCH Menu

Street view of a black storefront with a sign reading 'Goody Two Shoes, Vice & Vintages.' People are walking and sitting outside; some are standing in front of the shop. An American flag hangs on a pole next to the shop. The sidewalk has planters wit

A breakfast dish with a fried egg topped with green onions, served in a skillet with tortilla chips on the side, along with a small metal tray containing salsa, sour cream, and guacamole.

Interior of a stylish bar or restaurant with patrons sitting at the bar and tables, decorated with chandeliers, plants, and artwork.

Four people sitting at a marble table in a restaurant, smiling and holding drinks, with greenery decor and pink-patterned walls.

A waiting area with two marble-topped tables, black and yellow chairs, dark green leather banquettes, and two framed vintage posters on a textured wall, with two potted plants and decorative lighting.

A bartender with long hair tied in a bun and tattoos on his arms is preparing a cocktail behind a bar, pouring ingredients into a glass.

A cozy restaurant interior with a mix of seating options including marble tables, upholstered chairs, and banquettes. Elegant lighting fixtures hang from a wooden ceiling. Decor includes framed vintage posters, potted plants, and decorative wall piec

Man DJ wearing glasses and a tropical shirt, gesturing with hands while standing behind DJ equipment in a restaurant or cafe with decor on white brick walls and framed art.

A large salted pretzel on a white plate with small cups of mustard, a burger with fried onions and bacon on a bun, and a cone of French fries on a tray in a restaurant setting.

Five women sitting together at a restaurant table, smiling and posing for the photo. They are wearing sunglasses and casual summer clothing, with drinks on the table.

A woman with short blonde hair is sitting at a table in a restaurant, smiling and holding a glass of lemonade. She is wearing a black sleeveless top, coral-colored shorts, and several bracelets. She has a beige Gucci purse hanging on her lap and is w

Interior of a modern cafe with pink velvet chairs, a mural with food and drink illustrations, and bar-height tables with barstools along a wall. Decorative string lights hang from the ceiling.

A fried chicken sandwich with bacon, served with a side of French fries in a paper cone, on a white plate, with a decorative background.

Interior of a modern restaurant with a row of four marble-top tables with beige woven chairs and a black leather banquette. Each table has a small gold lamp, and a green floor lamp is in the corner. The wall is decorated with framed mirrors and glass

Exterior of a restaurant called 'Good Two Shoes' with black and white striped awnings, people standing outside, and a clear blue sky.

Interior of a modern lounge with a fireplace, patterned chairs, black velvet chairs, a small round table, and decorative lighting.

Person dipping a chicken wing into a dipping sauce in a basket of wings and vegetables on display.